Reverence Farms stands out for how carefully it documents its standards. Their herd of around 75 registered A2A2 Jersey cows is certified grass-fed and grain free by A Greener World and holds Animal Welfare Approved certification. The farm is also licensed and inspected by the state.

Calves stay with their mothers during the day, the land is managed with no synthetic fertilizers or pesticides, and the milk goes through regular third party testing. In North Carolina, a herdshare is the legal way to get raw milk. You buy a share of the herd, pay a boarding fee to cover the animals’ care, and in return you receive milk from the animals you co-own.

Our tip: Beyond milk, check their online store for grass-fed beef, lamb, pastured pork, and veal. It’s a great way to fill the freezer from the same farm.